Rum Maple Marshmallows

Delicate, creamy, and full of more fluff than my college literature professor, these marshmallows are the treat you never knew you wanted.

My boyfriend’s sister was kind enough to relent that the famous marshmallow recipe she had been using for years actually came from The Unofficial Harry Potter Cookbook, by Dinah Bucholz. With this basic marshmallow recipe being tested and true, Eric and I decided to give it the Gabric touch, thus experimenting with new and quirky flavor combinations that would make the unsuspecting consumer croon with melt-in-your-mouth joy.

It’s strange to think that marshmallows have been around for centuries. Of course, most of us are familiar with their early medicinal use to treat ailments such as a sore throat, but the history of these bad boys goes way back- the ancient Egyptians used parts of the marsh mallow plant to create delectable treats for their pharaohs and royalty, many times combining them with honey.

Eric and I decided to try them with rum. And much to our satisfaction, it worked.

Honestly, the process is both simple and beautiful. There is something so gratifying about watching a boiling liquid transform into the puffy, white squares we know and love! There is a true difference in texture between these soft, melty marshmallows and the ones you buy in the store.

Besides just eating these like popcorn, these marshmallows are incredible melted in a fresh cup of hot chocolate! Read on for the recipe, and find out yourself…

Rum Maple Marshmallows

Adapted by The Wildflour from The Unofficial Harry Potter Cookbook by Dinah Bucholz
Yields one 9 x 13 in. pan
Prep time: 15 min
Cook time: 20 min
Rest time: Overnight

1/2 c spiced rum (we used Bacardi Oakheart)
3/4 c light corn syrup
1/2 c maple syrup
1/2 c water
3 T gelatin
1/2 c powdered sugar, plus additional for dusting
2 c granulated sugar
1.4 tsp salt
1 T pure vanilla extract

  1. Spray and line a 9 x 13 in. pan with cooking spray and parchment, dusting with about 1/4 c of powdered sugar.
  2. Add 1/2 c water and the 3 T gelatin to mixing bowl (a stand mixer works best, here); allow to soften.
  3. Bring rum, corn syrup, maple syrup, sugar and salt to a boil in a saucepan, stirring constantly until a temperature of 238°F is reached.
  4. Slowly pour the piping hot liquid into the gelatin mixture one-half at a time, beating with whisk attachment on low speed.
  5. Increase speed to medium and add vanilla, then beat on high for approximately 12 minutes until mixture is thick and shiny.
  6. Scape the very sticky batter out onto your coated pan, smoothing out to all corners.
  7. Sprinkle the top with the rest of your powdered sugar and let rest uncovered overnight.
  8. Once solid, pull parchment onto countertop and coat your knife with powdered sugar, cutting through each sticky section. Dip each side of your squares in (yep, you guessed it) more powdered sugar until every chunk is evenly dusted and ready to enjoy!

Get incredible gluten-free recipes delivered directly to your inbox!

Leave a comment